The Medical Mimic of Spinal Epidural Abscess: A Neurosurgical Emergency Masquerading as Back Pain

Dr Neeraj Manikath , claude.ai

Abstract

Spinal epidural abscess (SEA) represents one of internal medicine's most treacherous diagnostic pitfalls—a life-threatening neurosurgical emergency that frequently masquerades as mundane musculoskeletal back pain. Despite its potentially catastrophic consequences, including permanent paralysis, SEA remains underrecognized in clinical practice, partly because back pain is ubiquitous and partly because the classic triad of fever, back pain, and neurologic deficit manifests in fewer than 15% of patients at initial presentation. This review provides internists and hospitalists with a practical framework for early recognition, emphasizing the critical "red flag" features that should trigger immediate advanced imaging and empiric treatment. We discuss the epidemiology, pathophysiology, high-risk populations, clinical presentation patterns, diagnostic approach, and management pearls that can prevent the devastating outcome of paraplegia.

Introduction

Back pain accounts for over 2.5% of all emergency department visits in the United States, making it one of the most common presenting complaints in clinical medicine. The vast majority of these cases represent benign, self-limited musculoskeletal conditions. However, buried within this sea of mechanical back pain are rare but catastrophic diagnoses that demand immediate recognition—and spinal epidural abscess stands among the most urgent.

The incidence of SEA has risen dramatically over the past three decades, from 0.2-1.2 cases per 10,000 hospital admissions in the 1970s to 2-8 cases per 10,000 admissions currently, representing a nearly five-fold increase. This rise parallels the opioid epidemic, increasing rates of diabetes mellitus, an aging population with more spinal instrumentation procedures, and improved diagnostic imaging availability. Despite increased awareness, diagnostic delays remain common, with studies showing average delays of 5-10 days from symptom onset to diagnosis. By the time neurologic deficits develop, the window for reversible intervention may have already closed.

Why Spinal Epidural Abscess is Rarely Discussed Yet Essential

Several factors contribute to SEA's status as an underappreciated diagnosis. First, its rarity creates low clinical suspicion—most internists will encounter only a handful of cases in their career. Second, early symptoms are nonspecific and overlap substantially with benign conditions. Third, the absence of fever does not exclude SEA; fever is present in only 50-70% of cases at initial presentation. Fourth, neurologic examination may be entirely normal in the early stages, providing false reassurance.

The stakes, however, could not be higher. SEA progresses through four clinical stages: (1) spinal pain at the level of infection, (2) radicular pain, (3) motor weakness and sensory changes, and (4) paralysis. Once paralysis develops, particularly if present for more than 24-48 hours, the prognosis for neurologic recovery becomes dismal regardless of intervention. Studies consistently show that patients with neurologic deficits lasting over 36 hours have less than 50% chance of meaningful recovery, while those treated before significant deficits develop have excellent outcomes.

Pathophysiology and Microbiology

The epidural space, located between the spinal dura mater and vertebral periosteum, contains fat, lymphatics, and the internal vertebral venous plexus (Batson's plexus). This valveless venous system allows bidirectional flow and provides a pathway for hematogenous seeding from distant infectious foci.

Three mechanisms account for most SEAs:

1. Hematogenous spread (50-60% of cases): Bacteremia from remote sources including skin and soft tissue infections, endocarditis, urinary tract infections, dental procedures, or infected IV drug injection sites. Batson's plexus facilitates this spread.

2. Contiguous spread (15-30%): Direct extension from adjacent osteomyelitis, discitis, or paraspinal abscesses. Vertebral osteomyelitis and discitis should always prompt consideration of epidural involvement.

3. Direct inoculation (10-15%): Following spinal procedures including epidural anesthesia, lumbar puncture, spinal surgery, or vertebral biopsy.

Staphylococcus aureus accounts for 60-70% of cases, with methicillin-resistant S. aureus (MRSA) comprising an increasing proportion. Streptococcal species represent 10-15% of cases. Gram-negative organisms including Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa occur in 10-15%, particularly in elderly patients, those with urinary tract sources, or IV drug users. Mycobacterium tuberculosis should be considered in endemic regions or immunocompromised patients. Fungal etiologies (Aspergillus, Candida) occur rarely, primarily in profoundly immunosuppressed individuals.

High-Risk Populations: Know Your Patient

Recognizing patients at elevated risk for SEA is fundamental to early diagnosis. The following populations warrant heightened vigilance:

Intravenous Drug Users: This population carries a 5-10 fold increased risk. Repeated needle contamination with skin flora, particularly S. aureus, creates recurrent bacteremia. Any IV drug user with back pain should be considered high-risk until proven otherwise.

Diabetes Mellitus: Patients with diabetes have a 3-5 fold increased risk due to impaired immune function, increased skin colonization with S. aureus, and higher rates of skin and soft tissue infections that can seed hematogenously.

Immunocompromised States: HIV/AIDS, chronic corticosteroid use (>5mg prednisone equivalent daily for >1 month), chemotherapy, transplant recipients, and biologic immunosuppressant use all increase susceptibility.

Recent Bacteremia or Endocarditis: Any patient with documented bacteremia within the preceding 4-8 weeks who develops back pain warrants immediate consideration of SEA. Infective endocarditis carries particularly high risk for metastatic seeding.

Chronic Kidney Disease and Hemodialysis: These patients have increased infection risk from vascular access sites and impaired immunity.

Recent Spinal Procedures: Epidural anesthesia, spinal surgery, or vertebral interventions within the past 3 months create direct inoculation risk.

Chronic Liver Disease and Alcohol Use Disorder: Both confer increased susceptibility through immune dysfunction.

Clinical Presentation: The Deceptive Simplicity

The textbook triad of fever, back pain, and neurologic deficit represents the late presentation of SEA, manifesting in only 10-15% of patients at initial evaluation. This triad's absence provides dangerous false reassurance.

The Red Flag History

When evaluating back pain, specific historical features should dramatically elevate suspicion:

"This is the worst back pain of my life": Patients with SEA frequently describe pain severity out of proportion to expected musculoskeletal causes. The pain is often described as deep, constant, and progressively worsening.

Pain unrelieved by position or rest: Unlike mechanical back pain that typically improves with recumbency, SEA pain is relentless. Patients report inability to find any comfortable position.

Pain onset: While SEA can present acutely, most patients describe pain evolving over several days to 2 weeks. Hyperacute onset (hours) is less typical and should also raise concern for other catastrophes including aortic dissection or epidural hematoma.

Night pain: Pain that awakens patients from sleep or prevents sleep entirely suggests non-mechanical etiology.

Constitutional symptoms: Fever, chills, night sweats, and malaise accompany SEA in 50-70% of cases. However, their absence does not exclude the diagnosis. Elderly and immunocompromised patients may lack fever despite severe infection.

Recent infections: Specifically inquire about recent skin infections, dental procedures, pneumonia, urinary tract infections, or any episodes of fever or bacteremia.

Physical Examination Pearls

The neurologic examination may be entirely normal in early SEA, creating a false sense of security. However, several examination findings warrant particular attention:

Localized spinal tenderness: Percussion tenderness over the spinous processes at the level of infection is present in 75% of cases. This finding is more specific than simple palpation tenderness. Use a reflex hammer to percuss sequentially down the spine—sharp, localized pain suggests underlying pathology.

Neurologic examination: A complete neurologic exam is mandatory but may be normal. Specifically assess:

• Motor strength in all extremities (MRC grading 0-5)
• Sensory examination including light touch, pinprick, and proprioception
• Deep tendon reflexes (hyperreflexia suggests cord compression)
• Plantar responses (Babinski sign indicates upper motor neuron involvement)

Saddle anesthesia: Perhaps the most critical examination finding is perianal sensation. Test pinprick in the perianal region bilaterally. Loss of sensation in the S4-S5 distribution (saddle anesthesia) indicates cauda equina syndrome and represents a neurosurgical emergency requiring intervention within hours.

Rectal examination: Check rectal tone. Decreased tone suggests cauda equina involvement. Also assess for perirectal abscess, which can seed epidurally.

Bladder dysfunction: Urinary retention or incontinence indicates advanced cauda equina syndrome. However, absence of bladder symptoms does not exclude significant cord compromise.

Pearl: The Progressive Nature

SEA typically progresses in a predictable sequence: back pain → radicular pain → weakness → paralysis. However, progression can be rapid, occurring over hours in some patients, or slow over weeks in others. Never assume time for serial examinations—when suspicion is high, act immediately.

Diagnostic Approach: Time is Spinal Cord

When to Image

The critical question facing internists is: Which patients with back pain require emergent advanced imaging? The following framework provides guidance:

High-Risk Patient + Severe Back Pain = MRI

Any patient with risk factors (IV drug use, diabetes, immunosuppression, recent bacteremia) presenting with severe, relentless back pain requires MRI evaluation regardless of whether fever or neurologic deficits are present.

Any Neurologic Deficit + Back Pain = STAT MRI

This is non-negotiable. Even subtle weakness, sensory changes, or reflex abnormalities in the context of back pain mandate immediate imaging.

Fever + Back Pain + Risk Factors = MRI

While fever is nonspecific, its presence in a high-risk patient with back pain requires exclusion of SEA.

Oyster: Plain Radiographs Are Useless

A critical mistake is ordering plain spine X-rays when SEA is a consideration. X-rays have no role in SEA diagnosis. They may show osteomyelitis or discitis if present but cannot visualize the epidural space. Ordering X-rays delays definitive diagnosis and treatment. If you are concerned enough to image the spine, order MRI.

The Gold Standard: MRI with Contrast

MRI with gadolinium contrast is the diagnostic modality of choice, with sensitivity and specificity exceeding 95%. T1-weighted images with gadolinium show rim-enhancing epidural collections. T2-weighted images demonstrate spinal cord edema and compression. MRI also identifies associated osteomyelitis, discitis, and paraspinal abscesses.

Technical pearl: Order MRI of the entire spine when SEA is suspected. While most abscesses occur in the thoracic and lumbar regions, skip lesions occur, and imaging only the symptomatic region may miss additional foci.

When MRI is Unavailable or Contraindicated

If MRI is contraindicated (pacemaker, certain metallic implants, severe claustrophobia) or unavailable, CT myelography represents the alternative, though it is invasive and has lower sensitivity. Emergent transfer to a facility with MRI capability should be considered for high-risk patients.

Laboratory Studies

While imaging provides the diagnosis, laboratory studies support clinical decision-making:

Blood cultures: Obtain two sets before antibiotics when possible. Positive in 50-60% of SEA cases and guide antibiotic therapy.

Complete blood count: Leukocytosis is common but nonspecific. Normal white blood cell count does not exclude SEA.

Inflammatory markers: ESR is elevated (>20 mm/hr) in over 95% of SEA cases, making it a sensitive (though nonspecific) screening test. CRP is similarly elevated. These markers are useful for monitoring treatment response.

Pearl: A normal ESR has high negative predictive value for SEA. In a low-risk patient with normal neurologic examination and normal ESR, SEA is unlikely (though not impossible).

Lumbar Puncture: Generally Contraindicated

Lumbar puncture has no role in SEA diagnosis and is potentially dangerous. It can introduce infection into the subarachnoid space, cause neurologic deterioration if cord compression exists, and delays definitive imaging. CSF analysis is nonspecific and cannot distinguish epidural from meningeal processes.

Management: The First Hours Matter

Empiric Antibiotics: Start Early

When clinical suspicion for SEA is high and imaging is ordered, do not wait for MRI results to initiate antibiotics if there will be any delay. The potential harm from delayed antibiotics exceeds the benefit of pristine blood cultures.

Empiric regimen for community-acquired SEA:

• Vancomycin 15-20 mg/kg IV every 8-12 hours (targeting MRSA)
• PLUS
• Ceftriaxone 2g IV daily (covering streptococci and some gram-negatives)

For IV drug users or nosocomial acquisition, consider broader gram-negative coverage:

• Vancomycin (as above)
• PLUS
• Cefepime 2g IV every 8 hours OR Meropenem 1-2g IV every 8 hours (latter preferred if recent healthcare exposure or critically ill)

For post-procedural SEA (spinal surgery, epidural anesthesia):

• Vancomycin
• PLUS
• Cefepime or Meropenem (covering Pseudomonas)

Once cultures and sensitivities return, narrow antibiotics accordingly. Total duration is typically 4-6 weeks of IV antibiotics for uncomplicated cases, longer if osteomyelitis is present.

Neurosurgical Consultation: Immediate

SEA is a neurosurgical emergency. Neurosurgery should be consulted emergently—not after imaging, but as soon as the diagnosis is suspected. Most patients require surgical decompression and drainage.

Indications for surgery:

• Neurologic deficits (relative emergency)
• Spinal instability
• Sepsis despite antibiotics
• Failure to improve with medical management

Medical management alone may be considered in highly select cases:

• No neurologic deficits
• Negative blood cultures
• Small abscess (<2-3 mm epidural thickening)
• Pan-sensitive organism
• Ability to monitor closely with serial neurologic exams

Even in these cases, neurosurgical consultation guides decision-making. Patients managed medically require daily neurologic assessments, repeat MRI within 48-72 hours, and immediate surgical intervention if clinical deterioration occurs.

The "Door-to-Decompression" Concept

Similar to door-to-balloon time in STEMI, SEA with neurologic deficits requires rapid surgical decompression. Studies show that decompression within 24 hours of paralysis onset yields significantly better outcomes than delayed surgery. Some data suggest benefit only if surgery occurs within 12-36 hours of motor deficit onset.

Hack: If you suspect SEA in a patient with neurologic deficits, think "spinal STEMI." Activate systems immediately—call neurosurgery, order STAT MRI, start antibiotics, and prepare for potential OR. Document exact time deficits began.

Special Populations and Scenarios

Diabetic Patients

Diabetics with SEA often have concomitant foot infections or pressure ulcers that serve as the primary source. They may have peripheral neuropathy complicating neurologic assessment. Diabetics also have higher rates of epidural lipomatosis, which can mimic or coexist with SEA on imaging.

IV Drug Users

These patients frequently have polymicrobial infections and may have concurrent endocarditis, psoas abscess, or septic arthritis. Detailed skin examination for injection site infections is essential. Consider echocardiography to evaluate for endocarditis. These patients often have lower pain thresholds from chronic opioid exposure, making pain assessment challenging.

Elderly Patients

Older adults may present atypically with confusion, falls, or functional decline rather than pain. They have higher rates of vertebral compression fractures that can confound diagnosis. Fever may be absent. Maintain lower threshold for imaging in elderly patients with acute back pain and risk factors.

Outcomes and Prognosis

Prognosis in SEA directly correlates with neurologic status at time of intervention. Patients treated before significant motor deficits develop have excellent outcomes with >90% full recovery. Those with complete paralysis for >48 hours have <30% chance of ambulation recovery regardless of treatment.

Mortality ranges from 5-15% in contemporary series, higher in elderly patients, those with comorbidities, and those with delayed diagnosis. Recurrence occurs in approximately 5% of cases, higher with inadequate antibiotic duration or persistent bacteremia source.

Conclusion and Key Takeaways

Spinal epidural abscess represents a diagnostic challenge where early recognition prevents catastrophe. Internists must maintain clinical suspicion in high-risk patients presenting with severe back pain, even without fever or neurologic deficits. The classic triad is a late finding—waiting for it means waiting too long.

Key action points:

1. Know your high-risk patients: IV drug users, diabetics, recent bacteremia
2. Recognize red flags: "worst pain ever," unrelenting pain, localized spinal tenderness
3. Examine for saddle anesthesia and rectal tone in every patient
4. Skip X-rays—order MRI with contrast for the entire spine
5. Start empiric antibiotics (vancomycin-based) without delay
6. Consult neurosurgery immediately, before imaging completion
7. Think "spinal STEMI" when deficits are present

Back pain is common; SEA is rare. But when SEA masquerades as mechanical pain, only vigilant pattern recognition and aggressive action prevent irreversible paralysis. This is internal medicine at its most crucial—recognizing the one in a thousand that changes everything.

References

1. Reihsaus E, Waldbaur H, Seeling W. Spinal epidural abscess: a meta-analysis of 915 patients. Neurosurg Rev. 2000;23(4):175-205.

2. Darouiche RO. Spinal epidural abscess. N Engl J Med. 2006;355(19):2012-2020.

3. Davis DP, Wold RM, Patel RJ, et al. The clinical presentation and impact of diagnostic delays on emergency department patients with spinal epidural abscess. J Emerg Med. 2004;26(3):285-291.

4. Rigamonti D, Liem L, Sampath P, et al. Spinal epidural abscess: contemporary trends in etiology, evaluation, and management. Surg Neurol. 1999;52(2):189-197.

5. Sendi P, Bregenzer T, Zimmerli W. Spinal epidural abscess in clinical practice. QJM. 2008;101(1):1-12.

6. Curry WT Jr, Hoh BL, Amin-Hanjani S, Eskandar EN. Spinal epidural abscess: clinical presentation, management, and outcome. Surg Neurol. 2005;63(4):364-371.

7. Pradilla G, Ardila GP, Hsu W, Rigamonti D. Epidural abscesses of the CNS. Lancet Neurol. 2009;8(3):292-300.

8. Tuchman A, Pham M, Hsieh PC. The indications and timing for operative intervention in noninfectious spondylodiscitis. Spine J. 2017;17(4):558-567.

9. Adogwa O, Karikari IO, Carr KR, et al. Spontaneous spinal epidural abscesses in patients 50 years of age and older: a 15-year institutional perspective. J Neurosurg Spine. 2014;20(3):344-349.

10. Mackenzie AR, Laing RB, Smith CC, Kaar GF, Smith FW. Spinal epidural abscess: the importance of early diagnosis and treatment. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1998;65(2):209-212.